Lee County · Pine Island
Old Florida island life — fishing villages, mangroves, and no high-rises
Home Search
Explore homes for sale in Pine Island with the Experience Real Estate Group office. Each search below opens in RealScout, where creating a free account linked to our office lets you save searches and get new-listing alerts — and an EREG Entrepreneur will follow up to guide you on your real estate journey.
Listing data is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change, or withdrawal.
Living Here
Pine Island is the largest island on Florida's Gulf Coast — a genuine slice of Old Florida connected to the mainland through the colorful village of Matlacha. There are no high-rises and no sandy beaches here; instead you'll find mangrove shorelines, working fishing villages, tropical fruit groves, and some of the best boating and fishing access in Southwest Florida along Charlotte Harbor and Pine Island Sound.
Known as the "Mango Capital" and a haven for anglers and artists, Pine Island spans several distinct communities — Bokeelia, St. James City, Pineland, Pine Island Center, and Matlacha. Properties range from canal-front and waterfront homes with private docks to affordable inland cottages and acreage, all wrapped in a quiet, authentic island pace.
Good to Know
Pine Island is Old Florida island life — fishing villages, mangrove shorelines, palm groves, and not a single high-rise. Its roughly 9,000 residents trade beaches for boat ramps, tarpon flats, and genuine quiet.
The island runs from Bokeelia's fishing piers in the north through Pineland and Pine Island Center to St. James City's canal homes in the south, with artsy Matlacha at the causeway.
Pine Island spans ZIP codes 33922, 33956, and 33993, about 40 minutes from Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) via the Matlacha causeway.
Use the search on this page for current Pine Island listings — canal homes in St. James City, acreage in Bokeelia, and everything between. An EREG Entrepreneur can match your boat draft to the right canal, which is half the battle here.
Explore
Bokeelia
The fishing village at Pine Island's northern tip, wrapped by Charlotte Harbor — one of the Gulf Coast's most productive estuaries. World-class fishing and boating with an unhurried, no-high-rises Old Florida pace.
St. James City
Pine Island's southern tip — a genuine fishing-village community on Pine Island Sound and Matlacha Pass, with direct Gulf-access boating and a laid-back island lifestyle that has changed little in decades.
Pineland
A historic area home to Calusa heritage sites and the Randell Research Center.
Pine Island Center
The island's commercial hub, with shops, services, and community gathering spots.
Matlacha
The colorful art village on the bridge to the island, full of galleries and waterfront dining.
Explore More
We value your privacy
This website uses necessary cookies to work properly and analytics cookies (Google Analytics) to understand how visitors use the site so we can improve it. Necessary cookies are always on. You can accept analytics cookies or decline them — your choice is saved for 12 months and you can change it anytime from the “Cookie Settings” link in our footer. Learn more in our Privacy Policy.